p-ISSN
2722-7782 | e-ISSN 2722-5356
DOI:� https://doi.org/ 10.46799/jsa.v4i6.611
COMPANY
PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT STRATEGY
AT
PT ANGKASA PURA 1 BRANCH OF GENERAL AHMAD YANI AIRPORT, SEMARANG
Dzaky Yogo
Ardhianza, Susilo Toto Raharjo
Diponegoro university
[email protected], [email protected]
Abstract
Business is a daily activity
that produces goods or services, has the aim of creating jobs, meeting daily
needs with goods and services, and improving the economy of society. Business
people must implement strategic steps due to increasingly fierce business
competition and the emergence of the Covid-19 pandemic resulting in paralysis
of the world economy (Agung, et. all 2022). analyze whether the cost leadership
strategy can improve revenue performance at PT Angkasa
Pura 1 Semarang. The research used is a type of qualitative research that
involves the use and collection of various materials derived from potential
data collection activities, namely by interviews, observations, and collecting
data as necessary from documents. Techniques used in data collection by
conducting in-depth interviews with respondents. Competitive strategy and
business strategy, which includes industrial organization, resource-based
viewpoints, dynamic capabilities, and theory. The overall cost leadership
strategy is implemented to gain competitive advantage by reducing operating
costs below operating costs incurred, cost suppression will have an impact on
low product selling prices, so as to attract consumers while still generating
profits. This research is qualitative research by conducting in-depth
interviews with resource persons both from internal and external companies,
where there is limited time to meet with resource persons because the interview
process is carried out during working operational hours and the many activities
of resource persons.
Keywords: Business, Cost leadership, Covid-19
INTRODUCTION
Business is the most
important thing and cannot be separated from society. Business can be
interpreted as an activity or activities carried out individually or in groups
by offering goods or services with the aim of obtaining profit (profit). In a
broad sense, business is a general term that describes the day-to-day
activities that produce goods or services. Business has several objectives,
namely to create jobs, meet daily needs with goods and services, and improve
the community's economy.
Coronavirus Disease 2019(COVID-19),
which was originally an epidemic in Wuhan China, has become a terrible epidemic
(Agung, et. all 2022). According to Dedi Junaedi (Dedi Junardi, 2020) explained
that "The threat of recession and even depression is in sight, even
countries as strong as Singapore, South Korea, Japan, the US, UK, France have
felt it, moreover Indonesia is also being affected, because in For two
consecutive quarters, national economic growth has contracted by up to 5.32%.
For the sake of business continuity, business people must implement strategic
steps because business competition is getting tougher and the emergence of the
Covid-19 pandemic has resulted in the paralysis of the world economy (Agung,
et. all 2022). Various impacts have been caused by the Covid-19 pandemic and
not a few sectors have been affected due to lack of income.
Covid-19 has become a
major disaster for all sectors including the global aviation industry (Miani,
et al., 2021). Many countries took action to enforce travel bans which resulted
in a drastic reduction in the number of passengers, and the number of flights
operating. In the case of companies that have businesses in the field of air
transportation that have international routes, they have to close their routes
due to the impact of Covid-19. Many airlines closed international route
services at the end of March 2020. For example, two major Australian airlines,
Qantas and Virgin Australia, canceled almost all scheduled international
flights. Australian states quickly followed the federal government's lead by
closing their borders to unauthorized foreign tourists.
airlineLow
cost carriers have been expanding their market share since the early 2000s, the
airline industry has become more cost sensitive, as competition to attract
airlines has increased (Choi et al., 2019), financial stability is increasingly
important to maintain increasingly competitive airport fees (Castillo-Manzano,
2010). However, Covid-19 raised concerns about the financial stability of the
aviation industry. The number of passengers has decreased drastically, so many
airlines face the risk of bankruptcy. As a result of Covid-19, each airport
loses an average of 50% of its connection and network efficiency is decreasing
(Sun et al., 2020). It is not yet known when the Covid-19 pandemic will end,
government regulations such as lockdowns or monetary penalties,
The Covid-19 pandemic
strengthened airport quarantine procedures. On 1 June, the International Civil
Aviation Organization (ICAO) announced new rules named �guidance for air travel
through the Covid-19 public health crisis� (ICAO, 2020). Airport operators are
required to complete additional procedures, including reinforcement of quarantine.
Passengers may be required to arrive at the airport earlier. However, it is
questionable whether changes in airport arrival times lead to increased
commercial revenues. How those changes affect passenger behavior, especially in
commercial facilities. According to an annual survey of 919 airports in fiscal
year 2017 by Airport Council International (ACI airport economics report,
2019), non-aeronautical revenue accounted for 40% of the total surveyed airport
revenue. Airports in Asia-Pacific and the Middle East, where non-aeronautical
activities are a familiar concept for airport operations, account for nearly
50% (Asia-Pacific: 47%, Middle East: 49%). During the Covid-19 pandemic, PT
Angkasa Pura 1 was one of the many other companies affected by the Covid-19
pandemic. An extraordinary impact emerged when the Implementation of
Restrictions on Community Activities (PPKM) was implemented, and the issuance
of new travel regulations using public transportation during the pandemic.
Before the pandemic and PPKM, in 2017 - 2019 PT Angkasa Pura 1 Semarang had
experienced an increase and decrease in the amount of traffic as shown in the
graphic below: During the Covid-19 pandemic, PT Angkasa Pura 1 was one of the
many other companies affected by the Covid-19 pandemic. An extraordinary impact
emerged when the Implementation of Restrictions on Community Activities (PPKM)
was implemented, and the issuance of new travel regulations using public
transportation during the pandemic. Before the pandemic and PPKM, in 2017 -
2019 PT Angkasa Pura 1 Semarang had experienced an increase and decrease in the
amount of traffic as shown in the graphic below: During the Covid-19 pandemic,
PT Angkasa Pura 1 was one of the many other companies affected by the Covid-19
pandemic. An extraordinary impact emerged when the Implementation of
Restrictions on Community Activities (PPKM) was implemented, and the issuance
of new travel regulations using public transportation during the pandemic.
Before the pandemic and PPKM, in 2017 - 2019 PT Angkasa Pura 1 Semarang had
experienced an increase and decrease in the amount of traffic as shown in the
graphic below:
Figure
1
In the traffic growth observations above, the movement of
passengers, cargo and aircraft increased from 2017 to 2018, but decreased in
2019. From 2020 to 2021 the movement of the number of flights and passengers
has again decreased significantly due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Regulations on
domestic travel restrictions contained in the SE of the Covid-19 Task Force
have further reduced the number of passengers. The Covid-19 pandemic came when
PT Angkasa Pura 1 was developing airports that were under capacity, the company
spent up to IDR 12 trillion for the construction of Yogyakarta International
Airport. Spending IDR 2.3 trillion to build a new terminal for Syamsudin Noor
International Airport, Banjarmasin, to develop the new terminal for Jenderal
Ahmad Yani International Airport in Semarang, the company spent Rp 2.03
trillion, and Rp 2.6 trillion for the development of Makassar's Sultan
Hasanuddin International Airport. The company funds all airport development and
construction through programs using various funding sources such as internal
funds and bank loans and bonds to maintain domestic flight routes and make
airports managed by PT Angkasa Pura 1 more attractive.
In 2019 PT Angkasa Pura 1's revenue reached up to Rp. 8.6
trillion, then decreased in 2020 to only 3.9 trillion, and in 2021 it
experienced a slight decline because the number of passengers decreased to 25
million. When the Covid-19 pandemic the company experienced difficult
conditions, experienced great pressure in the financial and operational sectors,
the company was required to make loan repayments that were previously used in
airport development investments when the traffic situation decreased and the
company's financial pressure. The world of aviation and tourism is one of the
industries most affected by the Covid-19 pandemic and it is not known when the
pandemic will end. The current pandemic conditions put pressure on the
operational and financial performance of PT Angkasa Pura 1. (Faik Fahmi, 2020)
The main director of PT Angkasa Pura 1 said, "under these conditions
management has prepared strategic initiatives to reduce the impact of the
pandemic on the performance of PT Angkasa Pura 1, by restructuring from an
operational and financial standpoint. In this case, asset recyling efforts were
made, intensification of accounts receivable collection, applying for tax
refunds, operational efficiency starting from traffic-based airport services,
organizational simplification, postponement of investment programs and
encouraging subsidiaries to carry out business transformation. This
restructuring program can strengthen the company's finances in the future,
especially the ability to ensure additional cash in income, cost efficiency and
fund raising efforts.
To increase other revenues, PT Angkasa Pura 1 carried out
a commercial transformation by forming a consortium with Incheon International
Airport Corporation (IIAC) and PT Wijaya Karya to form a Batam International
Airport PT to manage and develop Batam's Hang Nadim International Airport, in
addition to also working with PT Gudang Garam to build Dhoho Kediri Airport.
Developing Lombok International Airport in preparation for the Moto GP event in
Mandalika, then utilizing the land at Kelan Beach Bali as a Family Leisure
Park, Resort Villa, Retail Premium Outlet, Exhibition Hall and Warehouse and
developing Airport City at Yogyakarta International Airport.
PT Angkasa Pura 1 is trying to handle this situation so
that it quickly gets up and immediately performs the company's obligations to
creditors, partners on a regular and gradual basis. With this strategic
initiative, the company is optimistic that it will be able to survive in
difficult times and bounce back in 2022 so that it can record positive
operational results, and the goal of restructuring can be achieved up to Rp.
3.8 trillion, increasing the company's profitability to Rp. 704 billion and
increasing capital up to Rp. 3.5 trillion. With the development of airports
under the management of PT Angkasa Pura 1 on a consolidated basis, it will
increase the number of company assets, when the airport development project
begins to be implemented, the company's assets will continue to increase. In
2021 the company's assets will reach IDR 44 trillion, from only IDR 24 trillion
in 2017,
The company's total cost has decreased and increased
greatly, this has happened because PT Angkasa Pura 1 Semarang made several
additional human resources in 2020, and has also built airport operations with
the eco-airport concept which includes the land side and air side, with a
previous area of 58,652 m2 to 90,000 m2, along with the
construction of the previous runway (2,000 m) to (2,570 m), including the
construction of a rapid exit taxiway/RET (4,600 m2), and an expansion of the Apron
capacity of 104,543 m�. In accordance with the Reasonable Cost strategy, even
though there was an increase in operational costs, the company managed to
reduce operational costs below the target. Based on what the authors have
described above,
Based on the background described above, the air
transportation industry has experienced a major impact due to the Covid-19
pandemic, and has also affected the business performance of air transportation
companies. Based on these problems, the problem of this research is how to
maintain business performance and increase PT Angkasa Pura 1's revenue. In a
more specific effort related to the problems in this research, several research
questions are asked, as follows:
1. How did the company improve company performance during
the Covid-19 pandemic until now?
2. What strategy did the company take in dealing with the
crisis during the Covid-19 pandemic?
3. What happens if the company does not implement strategies
to improve performance?
Strategy
Strategy comes from the
Greek strategos andstrategos, which means knowledge and art regarding the
available resources of a company to achieve certain desired goals (Chandradhy
in Zulham, 2011: 32). Strategy is a pattern of goals as well as policies and
grand plans that have been designed in such a way as to achieve the company's
business goals (Anthony in Elhamma, 2013: 2).�
Strategy Evaluation. Strategy is something that
needs to be changed because it doesn't work as desired or because there are
major changes or improvements. Therefore, managers have an obligation to
monitor how well a strategy is performing and how well its implementation is
carried out, making adjustments if there is a better way to support the
company's operations (Nedelea and Paun,
2009: 101).
Economic Turbulence
Daon et al (2020) state
that most governments are aware that air travel plays an important role in the
spread of the Covid-19 virus, they close regional borders or limit travel.
Shepardson and Whittly (2020) say that since March
2020, the global aviation industry has experienced a 70-95% decline in
passenger demand. Khatib et al (2020) said the number of scheduled aircraft
movements decreased by 47.5% in August 2020,
ICAO and International Finance Companies (2020) say
this effect causes tough economic losses, not only for airports but also for
most stakeholders in the sector. Akbar and Kisilowski, Kao et al (2020) say
airlines have responded to this rapid decline in demand from a cost-saving
perspective by grounding most of their aircraft and providing employees with
time off. Based on ACI (2019) the situation at airports is slightly different,
fixed costs incurred to maintain and operate infrastructure components are a
sizeable part of the airport cost structure, with this airports are not easy to
make cost savings, the same is true for airlines.
Forsyth et al (2020)
show that airports need to achieve their viability through sufficient liquidity
to cover costs in the short and long term, they suggest that airports need to
increase flight costs to finance the Capital. However, while they indicated
that the government would direct airports not to increase aeronautical fares as
a regulator to safeguard the overall health of the industry in the long term,
this made it clear that airports should focus more on other sources of revenue,
such as post-Covid-19 commercial revenue.
Competition in the
Transportation Industry
80% of the airlines that
were present at the conference chose the second alternative provided by the
government in setting air freight rates, in contrast to the other 20% of
airlines preferring the first alternative in accordance with INACA policy.
However, the Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) considers that
the stipulation imposed by INACA previously violated Law No. 5 of 1999 concerning
Prohibition of Monopolistic Practices in Unfair Business Agreements, therefore
the Ministry of Transportation followed up on the determination of air
transport rates and submitted them directly with alternatives. rates are set
directly to the operator.
Government regulations
Michael Porter argued in
Porter Five Forces, that government regulation threatens newcomers to the
industry. Industries that involve government regulation, such as
telecommunications, healthcare, and airlines, have fewer competitors due to
potential difficulties in passing initial evaluations that would allow these
companies to legally begin providing services or distributing their products.
Production Cost
Efficiency
All economic expenses
incurred in producing an item are referred to as production costs, production
costs are expenses that have been made by companies to obtain production
factors and raw materials used in producing products.
Operational Cost Savings
Otman and Uli (2009) in
Haim Hilman and Narenthen Kaliappen (2014) say "cost leadership strategy
emphasizes that firms can gain competitive advantage by achieving low cost
within the industry" explains that cost leadership strategy can emphasize
low costs within companies to achieve competitive advantage . Generic strategy
is an alternative strategy within the company to achieve competitive advantage.
Evaluating Costs
Pearce and Robinsi
(2009) say that a business is said to be successful if it is built on the basis
of cost advantage, where the business is able to provide products or services
at a relatively lower cost than its competitors.
Pricing
Pricing strategies are
used by companies to determine prices for goods and services, alternative
pricing comes from marketing strategies formulated to achieve organizational
goals.
performance
The achievement of
implementing the activities of a program to realize the goals, vision and
mission of the company is called performance. Performance is an achievement
that has been achieved by the company within a certain period of time, company
performance is a picture of the company's financial condition that can be
analyzed with analytical tools so that the condition of the company can be
known. Conducting financial performance appraisal is one way that can be done
by management in order to fulfill obligations to donors and achieve company
goals optimally. It can be seen that performance is an indicator for companies
in making decisions, companies are able to interact with the internal or
external environment through information systems, then the information is
explained and summarized in financial reports.
Sales Strategy
Many have made changes
in their lives since the Covid-19 pandemic, one of which is the aviation
industry is also facing unprecedented changes in the management environment,
including increasing financial problems in all sectors. This study suggests
that the strategic direction at the airport focuses on commercial revenue
management. After the Covid-19 pandemic, safety and hygiene will be top priority.
As a result, there have been changes to airport operational procedures, the
most visible difference being the strengthening of the passenger health
condition verification process. Increased waiting time can be a by-product,
increasing dwell time having a more significant impact on increasing the
spending of existing buyers than creating new buyers. Airport operators can
introduce service differentiation perspectives, such as special services, to
cut passenger waiting times more precisely. Then, with the emergence of online
sales, it requires airport operators to change sales strategies. Prior to
Covid-19, there was little effort to align operating and commercial revenue
policies despite the increasing importance of revenue management.
Increase Revenue
������������� The
airport's main customers are impulse shoppers. Thus, airport operators should
pay more attention to encouraging impulse buying tendencies. In addition,
airport operators need to change their main promotion direction for commercial
facilitiesUnlucky. Traditionally, the main promotional direction has been to
provide information about product price or quality (for example, 10% less).
However, to stimulate an impulsive buyer's desire to buy, an emotional approach
can be more effective. For example, more and more airports are introducing
membership so that passengers feel treated and are more loyal. In addition, the
Singapore Changi Airport and Hong Kong Airport operating membership service
operators put more resources into emphasizing a pleasant travel atmosphere.
Research
Approach
The research used is a type of qualitative research that
involves the use and collection of various materials originating from potential
data collection activities, namely by interviewing, observing, and collecting
necessary data from documents. The technique used in collecting data by
conducting in-depth interviews with respondents. The instrument intended to
obtain qualitative data is in the form of informant responses from buyers and
suppliers with a wider range of information. The interview will use an
interview guide instrument, which is an open question to the informant, so that
the informant can answer more comprehensively. The results of the interviews
that have been conducted will then be summarized and concluded by the
researcher.
Research Participants
The participants or samples selected to support this
research were divided into two, namely internal and external companies. There
were 4 participants in the participants who helped carry out the research, as follows:
Table 1
Internal Participant
Position |
|
Fadlan Waluyono |
Senior Manager Airport Administration |
Agus Sina |
Senior Manager Airport Operations |
Ahmad Agung S |
Senior Manager Airport Commercial |
Table 2
External Participant
external |
Position |
Santiko |
Manager
A&W Fried Chicken |
Asih |
Manager
of Surabaya Caf� |
Research
Instruments
The research instrument used by the researcher used
direct interviews with each participant or informant that had been previously
selected by the researcher to obtain the complete required information.
Interviews were conducted face-to-face to get better, complete and accurate
results, and to avoid blank or incomplete answers to questions that were not
understood by the informant.
Data collection technique
Researchers used primary and secondary data types in this
study. Researchers used primary data from interviews with all participants as
well as discussions with other parties relevant to the research object, while
secondary data from data collection results through other media, both print and
electronic, including company documents deemed necessary. The data collection
process was carried out from October 2022 to December 2022, in the process data
collection was carried out directly through interviews at the participants'
locations and through secondary data collection through documents and books and
other relevant literature.
Evaluation
Criteria
Creswell (1998) points out that in qualitative research,
the aim is to achieve as best as possible to understand what can be described
as in-depth knowledge of some social setting or phenomenon. Striving for
understanding takes a lot of time in the field, so the verification process is
critical to evaluating the quality of qualitative research.
Empirical
Findings/Results
Financial Sector
During a pandemic, traffic
conditions had an impact on financial conditions in terms of the income aspect,
which experienced a significant decline. As an effort to get out of this
performance pressure, the company's management is currently preparing a planned
financial and operational restructuring scheme. With these various strategic
initiatives, we are optimistic that we can survive this difficult condition and
start to rise in 2022 and be able to record positive financial performance. One
of the company's strategies is to pay attention to all the rights of employees,
but there are indeed a number of things that cause a kind of delay but do not
have a significant impact.
Operational Sector
The Covid-19 pandemic has
put the company's financial and operational conditions under considerable
pressure, which has had a major impact on airport operational activities. The
airport gets revenue from the sale of services from the airport in the form of
PJP2U and of course that has a huge impact, when PPKM is carried out or when
the flight conditions set by the Covid-19 task force as well as central
government regulations are enforced. Psychologically, of course, passengers who
usually depart do not use flight conditions such as vaccines or restrictions on
aircraft capacity. There may be many passengers, especially air transport
passengers, who think of alternative transportation because at the time the
PPKM was implemented. Operational by traffic that has been determined by our
corporate will be carried out in the future,
Marketing Sector
Sales decreased in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic,
but have started to increase by around 40% from 2021 to 2022. It is hoped that
sales will continue to increase by around 10-15% from 2022 to 2023. customers
use air transportation and influence public interest, such as conducting direct
marketing to potential partners, benefiting from time and security in using air
transportation, and offering more competitive ticket prices.
Stakeholder Sector
First
Retail
A&W's turnover has decreased by 40 to 50 percent
from the years before the pandemic hit. Even though the current pandemic
conditions are not as bad as in 2020, the policy regarding pandemic prevention
at airports is still in effect. The decline in turnover that occurred at
A&W retail was not only due to the pandemic, but also because many tenants
at the airport had started to reopen, such as KFC, Kopi Kenangan
and other tenants. Currently, the main interest in A&W is regular customers
who already know about A&W's products and quality. On the other hand, not
all airport service users eat at A&W, this is due to other competitors that
attract visitors, for example KFC. The interest of service users at the airport
is very varied.
Second
Retail
Sales from Surabaya Cafe have increased even though
they have not returned to what they were before the pandemic, because the
number of passengers at the airport is not as many as before, and the many
other tenants also affect the number of customers visiting Surabaya Cafe.
Despite the increase in sales, sales from Surabaya Cafe are not enough to cover
the rental costs at the airport. The percentage of shortages to cover rental
costs is around 20%, this is slightly better than last year's shortfall during
the pandemic which experienced quite a severe minus.� Even so, the Ahmad Yani airport, there is no difference in rental prices from
previous years until now, both from before the pandemic to the pandemic. Where
the airport continues to increase the rental price every year.
RESULT
AND DISCUSSION
Financial Sector
From the results of the
interviews, it was concluded that various strategic initiatives and optimism
can withstand this difficult condition and start to rise in 2022 and can record
positive financial performance. One of the company's strategies is to pay
attention to all the rights of employees, but there are indeed a number of
things that make a kind of delay but do not have a significant impact, it's
just a matter of time or technique that is paid to all of these employee rights
that have been fulfilled by the company, in conditions at the beginning of the
2020 pandemic, the company has one of the strategic steps, one of which is
rationalizing the number of employees by managing traffic-based operations.
This can suppress or in terms of cost leadership, companies can prioritize
costs which are only important points.
Operational Sector
From the results of the
interview above, it can be concluded that the Covid-19 pandemic has put the
company's financial and operational conditions under considerable pressure, the
company continues to try to generate income by inviting people to return to
using air transportation services that air transportation is safe
transportation, by adding lots of food centers or spending to attract service
users. For the sake of customer satisfaction, the company provides the best
service, while continuing to carry out the operational by traffic strategy that
has been set by the corporate, which will also be a key for the company, so it
is hoped that with this strategy there will be no more wasted operational
costs, so that operations can be adjust the optimal cost.
Marketing Sector
From the interview above, it can be concluded that it
is important to carry out promotions through social media such as Instagram,
but also emphasizes that socializing the airport personally to entrepreneurs
and prospective passengers is also important. To maintain interest and sales,
companies must maintain service quality, maintain and improve existing brands,
and map out suitable areas for various types of brands. Local brands can also
compete with foreign brands, but there is a need to carry out training related
to packaging brands, and evaluation must continue to be carried out on existing
brands to adjust and optimize their placement in the airport area.
Stakeholder Sector
First
Retail
From the results of the interview above, it can be
concluded that the COVID-19 outbreak has had a major impact in various areas of
life, one of which is in the economic field. The current good sales conditions
in all sectors changed immediately. The impact on economic activity in all
sectors is not because of the Covid-19 virus as the object, but regulations
related to the Covid-19 virus in the form of restrictions on social relations
(social distancing) and PSBB (Large-Scale Social Restrictions) which causes the
business sector to be temporarily paralyzed because only a few business units
are allowed to operate during the PSBB. The impact that the airport management
has had on retail A&W has had quite a positive impact and has increased.
The strategy implemented by A&W to attract customers is by increasing from
the hospitality side,
Second
Retail
From the results of interviews that have been conducted,
the impact of the pandemic continues to haunt the national economy. Several
things happened that resulted in reduced income for the community, loss of jobs
and reduced community activities. This risk creates social problems that impact
the economy, for example some food tenants at the airport are also experiencing
the impact of Covid, because during Covid-19 the airport was closed for several
months and reopened but with rules limiting community activities, as well as
reduced flight schedules so that a decrease in the number of passengers who
will come to the airport. However, after struggling side by side with the
pandemic for 2 years, the airport and tenants at the airport are starting to
feel the impact as before, slowly starting to get busy again.
CONCLUSION
Based on the research process and various qualitative
data processing through an in-depth interview process with the addition of
traffic reports, estimation reports and financial realization at PT Angkasa Pura 1 Jenderal Ahmad Yani Airport Semarang, the results of the research are in
accordance with the objectives, it can be concluded as follows:
1.
Competitive
strategy and business strategy, which includes industrial organization,
resource-based viewpoints, dynamic capabilities, and theory.
2.
The
overall cost leadership strategy is implemented to gain a competitive advantage
by reducing operational costs below the operational costs incurred, cost
suppression will have an impact on product selling prices which are low, so as
to attract consumers while still generating profits.
3.
A
successful company must have a strategic plan in order to ensure a solid
position in the market, so as to get the desired results. Competitive advantage
is the key to large earnings and long-term success. The best performing
companies have managers who are deeply involved in implementing the chosen
strategy and ensuring that the strategy goes according to plan. Each company
can determine different strategies, according to the advantages and uniqueness
of the company's resources.
4.
Cost
leadership strategy can emphasize low costs within the company to achieve
competitive advantage. Generic strategy is an alternative strategy in companies
to achieve competitive advantage, companies are able to pursue cost leadership
strategies by making production efficiencies, and saving operational costs. The
cost leadership strategy is a strategy that has good performance compared to
other strategies, then the differentiation strategy is better than the other
strategies.
5.
A
business is successful when built on a cost advantage basis, the business is
able to provide products or services at a relatively lower cost than its
competitors. The cost advantage must be related to those that have been
identified as the following:
a.
Developing
innovations to lower production costs.
b.
Redesign
in determining the number of product components.
c.
Provide
training on employee safety in order to reduce the occurrence of work accidents
that result in cessation of production.
d.
Perform
maintenance on the company's operations to reduce overhead costs.
6.
The
airport's main customers are impulse shoppers. Thus, airport operators should
pay more attention to encouraging impulse buying tendencies. In addition,
airport operators need to change their main promotion direction for commercial
facilities. Traditionally, the main promotional direction has been to provide
information about product price or quality (for example, 10% less). However, to
stimulate an impulsive buyer's desire to buy, an emotional approach can be more
effective. For example, more and more airports are introducing membership so
that passengers feel treated and are more loyal.
The cost leadership strategy and differentiation
strategy have superior performance compared to other strategies. Strategy
refers to company planning and activities that are regulated by management by
optimally utilizing company resources to achieve company goals.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ACI,
(2019). Airport Economics Report. Airport Council International.
ACI, (2020). Airport Key Performance Index. Airport Council
International.
Adamoko, Samuel., and Danso, Albert. (2014).
International Journal of Management & Organizational. Financial Literacy
and Firm performance: The moderating role of financial capital availability and
resource flexibility. 3.www.ijmos.net/wpcontent/uploads/.../Adomako-Danso.pdf
Awwad, AS, Al-Khattab, AA, & Anchor, J. R (2013).
Competitive Priorities and Competitive Advantage in Jordanian Manufacturing.
Journal of Service Science and Management, 6, 69-79.
Agung Wahyu Wicaksono, Imam Sonhaji, Ahmad Mubarok,
(2022) Analysis of Aviation Services During the Pandemic and Perspectives on
the Recovery of Aviation Services in Indonesia, (SKYHAWK: Indonesian Aviation
Journal) Vol 2 No. 1 Year 2022
Castillo-Manzano, JI, (2010). Determinants of commercial
revenues at airports: lessons learned from Spanish regional airports. Tourism
Management. 31(6), 788-796.
Chan Budiman and Devie, (2013), The Effect of Student
Satisfaction on Competitive Advantage with University Reputation and Student
Loyalty as Intervening Variables, Business Accounting Review, Vol. 3, No. 1,
January: 386-397
Chepchirchir, Alice, B., Omillo, Francis., and Munyua,
Jennifer. (2018). European Journal of Management and Marketing Studies. Effects
of Cost Leadership Strategy on Organizational Performance of Logistics
Companies at Jomo Kenyatta International Airport, Kenya, 3(3), 76-86.http://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1445437.
Choi, JH, Wang, K., Xia, W., Zhang, A., (2019).
Determining factors of air passenger transfer airport choice in the Southeast
Asia�North America market: managerial and policy implications. Transport. Res.
Pol. Pract. 124, 203�216.
Choi, Jong Hae. (2021). Changes in airport operating
procedures and implications for airport strategies post-COVID-19. 94. 1-13.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jairtraman.2021.102065.
Creswell, JH (2015). Qualitative Research and Research
Design. Yogyakarta: Learning Library.
David, Fred R (2012), Strategic Management: A competitive
Advantage Approach, concept, Fourteenth Edition, New Jersey, Pearson Education
Inc.
Dedi Junaedi (2020), The Impact of the Covid-19 Pandemic
on the Economic Growth of Affected Countries, (National Symposium on State
Finance, page 995)
Grinerud, Katrine., Aarseth, Wenche, Kristin., and
Robertsen, Rolf. (2020). Business Research & Transportation Management.
Leadership Strategy, Management Decisions and Safety Culture in Road Transport
Organizations. 41, 1-11.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rtbm.2021.100670.
Handayani, S., & Alriani, IM (2016). Building a
Sustainable Competitive Advantage Through a Culture of Innovation. Journal of
Economic Management Accounting, 23(41).
IATA. (2020). Industry loss to top $84 billion in 2020.https://www.iata.org/en/pressroom/pr/2020-06-09-01/.
Inne, P. Rahma., Yustini, Tien., and Hendro, Omar.
(2020). MBIA. Analysis of the Implementation of Cost Leadership, Market
Expansion, and Business Process Streamlining Strategies on the Performance of
PT Semen Baturaja (Persero) Tbk, 19(2), 186-198.https://doi.org/10.33557/mbia.v19i2.969.
Kimiti, Paul, G., Muathe, Stephen, MA., and Murigi,
Elishiba, M. (2020). International Journal of Management Research, Innovation
& Entrepreneurship. Cost Leadership Strategies, Competitive Advantage, and
Performance: A Cross-sectional Study in the Context of Dairy Processing
Companies in Kenya, 6(2), 64-76.https://doi.org/10.18510/ijmier.2020.627
Kholida Qothrunnada, Business: Definition, Purpose, Types
and Examples,https://finance.detik.com/news-economy-business/d-6049917/business-pengertian-purpose-tipe-dan-exampleaccessed on 18 November 2022 at 18.45 WIB
Kontan.co.id. "surviving during the pandemic,
Angkasa Pura I reduced opex and capex by more than 30%". Friday, 04
September 2020.https://industri.kontan.co.id/news/bertahan-di-masa-pandemi-angkasa-pura-i-reduction-opex-dan-capex-lebih-dari-30.
Accessed January 25, 2022
Lukman Nul Hakim, (2013), Review of Qualitative
Methodology: Interviews with Elites, Center for Assessment, Management of Data
and Information (P3DI) Secretariat General of the DPR RI.
Miani, P., Kille, T., Lee, SY, Zhang, Y., Bates, PR,
(2021). The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on current tertiary aviation
education and future careers: Students' perspective. Journal of Air Transport
Management 94, 10208.
Monsur, SHT & Yoshi, T. (2012). Improvement of Firm
Performance by Achieving Competitive Advantages Through Vertical Integration in
the Apparel Industry of Bangladesh. Asian Economic and Financial Review, 2(6),
687-712.
Mulyadi (2015) Cost Accounting, 5th Edition. Yogyakarta:
College of Science������������� YKPN
Management.
Nurdin, Zulfa. (2016). Smoke-Free Area Innovation in
Bone-Bone Village, Baraka District, Enrekang Regency. Makassar: Hasanudin
University Makassar.
Oum, TH, Wang, K., (2020). Socially optimal lockdown and
travel restrictions for fighting communicable viruses including COVID-19.
Transport Pol. 96, 94-100.
PT Angkasa Pura 1 Semarang, (2021). 2017-2020 Operational
Plan Report.
PT Angkasa Pura 1 Semarang, (2021). Company Work Plan and
Budget 2019, 2020, 2021
Rahmadani & Siti Qomariah, (2022), Creating
Sustainable Competitive Advantage With Human Resource Management Strategies in
the World of Education, Ministry of Religion Research & Development Agency,
UIN Sultan Aji Muhammad Idris Samarinda 2022, Tarbiyah Wa Ta'lim: Journal of
Education and Learning Research. Vol. 9, No.2
Grab it, Freddy. (2006) SWOT Analysis and Business
Analysis Techniques and Strategies, (Jakarta: PT. Gramedia Pustaka, 2006), p. 4
Sa'ud, Udin Syaefudin. (2014). Educational Innovation.
Bandung: Alphabet
Sedarmayanti, (2014). Human Resource Management
Bureaucratic Reform and Management of Civil Servants. Bandung: Refika Aditama
Sun, X., Wandelt, S., Zhang, A., (2020). How did COVID-19
impact air transportation? A first peek through the lens of complex networks.
J. Air Transport. Manag. 89, 101928.
Law No. 5 of 1999 concerning the Prohibition of
Monopolistic Practices in Unfair Business Agreements
Wheelen, Thomas L. & Hunger, J. David, (2012),
Strategic Management and
Zhang, L., Yang, H., Wang, K., Zhan, Y., Bian, L. (2020).
Measuring imported case risk of COVID-19 from inbound international flights�A
case study on China. J. Air Transport. Management. 89, 101918.
Copyright holder: Dzaky Yogo Ardhianza,
Susilo Toto Raharjo (2023) |
First publication
right: |
This article is
licensed under: |